Job Training: Cultivating the Middle-Skill Workforce


15th July 2013

I relocated to Harlem in the summer of 2011, and upon moving in promptly called the cable company. It turned out the cable installer had grown up in a public-housing complex just a few blocks north of my apartment. He’d completed an apprenticeship program several years earlier, and as we chatted it was clear he was acutely aware of how lucky he was. He had a steady income and decent pay—a rarity among his friends—and he owed it to a cousin who had stumbled upon the training program. A happy coincidence, but one that highlights a major weakness in today’s middle-skill training efforts.

Broadly defined, “middle-skill” jobs are those that require more than a high-school diploma but less than a bachelor’s degree—including occupations as diverse as electricians, police officers, radiologic technicians, paralegals, and cable installers.

Although middle-skill jobs as a share of overall employment have shrunk, they still make up 48 percent of all employment in the country today—nearly 70 million jobs. Further, wage gains in these occupations often outpace national averages—with annual salaries in some categories topping $70,000. Finally, many of the middle-skill industries—welding, speech therapy, plumbing, and a whole host of others—are not easily outsourced, offering job security in addition to income gains. Simply put, these are good jobs.

So while we have to generate an estimated 21 million jobs by 2020 to return to full employment, the United States also needs to address the looming shortfall in skilled workers—an estimated three million by 2018. If we take advantage of the moment by building a robust middle-skill education and training architecture, we may be able to speed the recovery and rebuild the core of a sustainable middle class.

The decades-long decline of unionization weakened the training architecture for middle-skill workers; the funding and number of U.S. apprenticeship programs (which often relied on union infrastructure) decreased by 36 percent over the past 15 years. Further, private-sector investment in training is constrained by a range of market failures, in addition to legitimate concerns that training investments cannot be recouped if workers subsequently move to competitors.

The good news is that we have a blueprint for a comprehensive U.S. middle-skill training architecture. Examples abound: In the utility sector (in which up to 60 percent of the workforce will need to be replaced in the next ten years), it is the Center for Energy Workforce Development, a collaboration launched in 2006 between multiple utilities and unions to create a pipeline of technicians. In Kentucky, it is Metropolitan College, launched in 1998 by UPS, the state, the city of Louisville, and several community colleges to train around 2,000 students each year for UPS air-hub operations. In health care, it is the initiative sponsored by Kaiser Permanente and its unions, which offers more than 50 training programs across the health-care field with a 95 percent retention rate of the registered nurses it trains. These programs, whether centered around a region, an industry cluster, or a community college, share some common features: linking training to specific hiring needs; providing financial support for students (especially adult learners); and focusing on post-training placement.

The problem isn’t the lack of ideas. It’s scale. While every state has some kind of skills initiative, none of these efforts has the capacity to address the anticipated 2018 shortfall. The Obama Administration has taken several steps, including the launch of Skills for America’s Future, a public-private initiative to facilitate partnerships among employers and community colleges nationwide. And the Department of Labor is granting $2 billion over four years to finance expansion of community-college training programs.

However, it is the Administration’s more recent proposal that could be transformative. The $8 billion “Community College to Career Fund” would be co-administered by the Departments of Education and Labor to establish partnerships between community colleges and businesses to train two million workers.

Like many ideas in Washington these days, the fund proposal has fallen by the wayside, yet another victim of the near-absolute preoccupation with fiscal austerity. In theory, this idea should have strong bipartisan support—last time I checked, it’s pretty good politics to be in favor of facilitating work. However, recent disagreements over reform of the Workforce Reinvestment Act, currently the primary workforce-training program at the federal level, suggest philosophy is trumping action at least in the short term.

For now, we must rely on initiatives that do not require significant federal funding—with the support of state and local government, the private sector, unions, and philanthropy to pick up the slack. Here are three ideas that don’t need federal action and can help make progress while we agitate for action in Washington:

Accelerate common standards. Workforce development experts have long identified the need for a national transferable and stackable certification system. A stackable certification—the kind that has become standard for companies like Microsoft, Oracle, and Cisco—provides a clearly defined system of industry-recognized competencies tied to job opportunities and career advancement. More recently, a range of industry associations, educational institutions, and states have developed such skills-certification systems. But we now may be suffering from too much of a good thing. Workers and employers struggle to make sense of the 700,000 different certificates available nationally. A logical fix is to simplify and streamline training by industry sector. The National Governors Association could take the lead on this, borrowing the idea of the common core standards initiative in the K-12 arena. By making the credentialing challenge a major priority, it could corral the multitude of stakeholders across industries and states—and do so quickly.

Apprenticeship investment fund. Union membership is at a 97-year low. Yet over the last few years the annual Manpower Inc. talent shortage survey shows that the skilled trades are the hardest employment sector to fill. Although the AFL-CIO and Change to Win-affiliated unions sponsor apprenticeship programs across the country, such efforts should be scaled up further. To take advantage of the current union talent on the cusp of retirement, a union-financed National Apprentice Investment Fund could focus on expanding such programs in every sector facing shortages. This could be modeled roughly after the Employer Investment Fund structure used in the United Kingdom’s film and other industries to facilitate employer involvement in skills training. A percentage of union dues (possibly allowing partial repayment from employers and dues from new union members) could be used as a financing source.

An X Prize for data integration. We need to use twenty-first-century IT tools to meet the challenge of matching workers with training opportunities and potential employers. The lack of transparency surrounding educational and employment data is puzzling. I can find a dim sum restaurant in Boise, Idaho in two seconds, but somehow a national jobs database is elusive. Philanthropists should challenge the tech industry to develop a simple, national, searchable database of available jobs, requirements, and credentialing opportunities (the latter with user rankings a la Yelp). In the ideal world, users would complete a simple checklist of current skills that would yield a list of available jobs and certifications that match. Once that is built, we then need to challenge our best minds and leading tech companies—Google, Facebook, Amazon—to deploy it creatively on a national basis.

There is no real substitute for the federal government in bringing public policy ideas to scale. But we cannot wait for Washington to get its act together. The United States has a window of opportunity right now to build a stronger national architecture for middle-skill training. If we move with national purpose, we could have a “three-fer”: addressing looming shortages in critical skills; moving low-skill workers up the economic ladder; and helping to reduce poverty and spur growth. If we act now, we can ensure the future cable guy doesn’t have to rely on a savvy cousin to find a path to the middle class.


Trusted Counsel in a Turbulent World


The Firm

Macro Advisory Partners was founded in 2013 to provide a global client base with a competitive advantage in a complex world. Driven by a belief in the value of independent, long-term strategic counsel, we created a firm that delivers actionable macro strategies to decision-makers in business, finance and the not-for-profit sector.

A volatile and fragmenting global landscape requires an integrated understanding of the political and economic drivers of change. Drawing on MAP's unique network, the firm’s partners create tailored and innovative macro solutions mapped to the specific exposures, risks and opportunities facing the firm’s clients.

MAP's London and New York-based team of partners, directors and associates is supported by a Global Advisory Board and a group of Senior Advisors drawn from leadership positions in the worlds of business, finance, politics, diplomacy and technology.


Macro Advisory Partners provides corporate, investor and foundation clients with the strategic insights to navigate the intersection of global markets, geopolitics and policy.

In a world defined by volatility and uncertainty — and an abundance of information, yet scarcity of insight — we identify the strategic implications for decision-makers tasked with maximising opportunity and minimising risk. The Archipelago World is characterised by fragmenting markets, populist politics, policy unpredictability, revolutionary technology, and weaponised arenas of finance, regulation and cyber.  The implications of this environment are dramatic and lasting. To help our clients anticipate and navigate these shifts in the macro landscape, we bring together deep on-the-ground analysis with long-term strategic judgement tailored to our clients' specific interests, exposures and concerns.

For today's global investor and business leader, macro is just as disruptive a factor as technology. Our advice — delivered by the firm's partners through trusted, personal, long-term and dynamic client engagements — is drawn from the policy expertise and connectivity of our global network. The firm's Global Advisory Board and a team of Senior Advisors with backgrounds in diplomacy, intelligence, investment strategy, negotiation, academia and industry, support our partners with the judgements that enable us to provide clients with relevant, actionable and investable macro solutions.


A culture of partnership defines our firm — among the individuals we have attracted to our endeavour, and with the clients whose long-term interests we view as our own. Our team brings to our work a diverse range of global business, finance and not-for-profit sector experiences that enable us not only to interpret a changing macro environment for our clients, but also to design specific solutions that enhance their performance and prospects.

The principles of independence, integrity and intelligence define our culture. Our clients include the world's leading technology, consumer, energy and financial services institutions. Our commitment to them — and to our people — is to deliver on our founding aim of building the world's leading macro advisory firm.


  • Article
    September 2015

    The Weaponization of Everything: Globalization’s Dark Side

    The element of surprise in international relations appears more frequent and more ferocious. Are these shocks to be expected from a dangerously fragile...
  • Article
    June 2015

    Arming Ukraine Will Put the West in Danger

    A dangerous, possibly irreversible, dynamic of conflict is taking hold of Russian-Western relations. In every arena of the Ukraine crisis, escalation is the...
  • Article
    February 2015

    The Limits of Security

    The War Studies 2015 Annual Lecture, Kings College London John Sawers, Chairman, Macro Advisory Partners Dr Strangelove came out in 1964. US President Peter...
  • Article
    January 2015

    The Real Arab Demand

    Two years in the life of the Arab Awakening already feels like an exhausted century, with the pendulum swinging from exuberance to extreme fear. Reckonings...
  • Article
    September 2014

    To Build a Coalition Against Islamic State, US Must Try a Little Humility

    When President Barack Obama assumed the presidency of the United Nations Security Council on Wednesday, he summoned the full weight of U.S. power to a cause...
  • Article
    March 2014

    Russia’s Model Behaviour in the Ukraine

    Russia's Model Behavour in the Ukraine: the Fragmenting Geopolitics of the Future Surprise is the least forgivable sin of statecraft – and yet nothing has so...
  • Article
    February 2014

    European Elections 2014 Report

  • Article
    September 2013

    For the UN Syria is both Promise and Peril

    The agreement between the United States and Russia to rid Syria of chemical weapons should please — but also terrify — anyone hoping to return the United...
  • Article
    September 2013

    How to Win the Vote – and War – in Syria

    President Barack Obama’s surprise decision to seek congressional authorization for punitive cruise missile strikes against Syrian government targets presents...
  • Article
    July 2013

    Job Training: Cultivating the Middle-Skill Workforce

    I relocated to Harlem in the summer of 2011, and upon moving in promptly called the cable company. It turned out the cable installer had grown up in a public-...
  • Article
    June 2013

    Turkey’s Crisis is Not About Erdogan

    The decision by Turkish authorities to send the riot police in to clear Taksim Square — while expressing a more conciliatory tone in a meeting between the...
  • Article
    May 2013

    Wheels Spinning, Going Nowhere

    An economic recovery in the UK demands that the incoming Bank of England governor, Mark Carney, (who takes up his post in July) runs a loose monetary policy...
  • Article
    April 2013

    Great-Power Myopia

    The narcissism of small differences is not usually associated with great-power politics. The pathology of turning minor disputes into major divisions between...
  • Article
    March 2013

    Iran Crisis is More Stable than it Seems

    The long-running crisis over Iran’s nuclear programme has met its moment of truth. This is the year when war or peace will break out – or so at least a...
  • Article
    November 2012

    Uncertainty is Not Going Away

    This week, within the space of 48 hours, the United States elected its next president and the Chinese Communist Party will convene in Beijing to begin the...
  • Article
    August 2012

    A World Without Europe Spells Danger and Woe

    The return of Europe’s sovereign debt crisis is redefining the region’s relationship with the outside world. Whether or not the euro holds together, the...
  • Article
    June 2012

    Getting Down to Business in Rio

    Where’s the voice of business when you need it? For governments in the West, this has been a common refrain of the financial and economic firefighting over the...
  • Article
    June 2012

    Let’s End the Empty Talk about Syria

    In every conflict, there are clarifying moments of horror, episodes that cast into stark relief the reality of the forces at work and the complex obstacles to...
  • Article
    May 2012

    Europe’s Imperiled Institutions

    The euro zone crisis has spared few pillars of the nearly 60-year-old European project. The chasm between elite purpose and popular support is widening by the...
  • Article
    April 2012

    China’s War of the Oligarchs

    The death of an Englishman in Chongqing has acquired all the intrigue of a John le Carré novel with none of its charms. Despite the occasionally romantic...
  • Article
    April 2012

    Cold War Lessons Can Help Disarm Iran

    Saturday’s talks in Istanbul between Iran and the five permanent members of the UN Security Council plus Germany are testimony to the power of diplomacy backed...
  • Article
    March 2012

    Separate Myth from Reality at Goldman

    In April 2006, the cover of The Economist featured the image of a mountain climber and the words: “On Top of the World: Goldman Sachs and the Culture of Risk...
  • Article
    February 2012

    In the Middle East, a Bonfire of Alibis

    Syria can set fire to Lebanon at the wave of a hand. Hezbollah can be ordered into battle with Israel at the command of a call from Tehran. Lebanon’s sectarian...
  • Article
    January 2012

    The Elephants in the Davos Ski Lodge

    The epic global shifts of 2011 transformed the political, economic, and social landscape from Shanghai to Sao Paolo, Washington to Cairo. No leader (not even...


180 Piccadilly
London W1J 9HF
Tel: +44 207 917 9947

New York
200 Park Avenue South
Suite 1117
New York, NY 10003
Tel: +1 212 602 8721